Research

Coinbase Base App Revolution: Why This Crypto Super App Could Change Everything

The Coinbase Base app represents a potentially transformative moment in crypto infrastructure. By combining social features, trading capabilities, and developer tools into a single platform, it could become the primary gateway for mainstream crypto adoption.
Token Metrics Team
6 min
MIN

The cryptocurrency industry is witnessing a paradigm shift as major exchanges race to build comprehensive "super apps" that consolidate trading, social features, and DeFi into single platforms. Leading this revolution is Coinbase's Base app, a ambitious project that could redefine how users interact with crypto.

What is the Base App?

The Base app represents Coinbase's vision of a crypto "everything app" – think WeChat for the blockchain era. Built on Coinbase's Layer 2 solution, Base, this platform integrates multiple crypto functions into one seamless experience:

Core Features

1. Centralized & Decentralized Trading

  • Full Coinbase exchange access
  • Integrated DEX trading (Aerodrome, Uniswap, others)
  • Real-time price discovery across venues
  • Professional trading tools for retail users

2. Social Creator Economy

  • Zora-powered social feeds
  • Creator coin monetization
  • Weekly reward distributions
  • Direct creator-to-fan interactions

3. Mini App Ecosystem

  • Farcaster-powered applications
  • Gaming and entertainment
  • DeFi protocol interfaces (Morpho, others)
  • Developer-friendly SDK

4. Integrated Payments

  • Base Pay for USDC transactions
  • Merchant integrations
  • Cross-border payments
  • Traditional payment rails bridge

The Technical Foundation: Farcaster Integration

What is Farcaster?

Farcaster serves as the technical backbone for the Base app's social and mini-app functionality. As a decentralized social networking protocol built on Ethereum, Farcaster enables:

  • Decentralized Identity: User-owned social graphs
  • Mini App Development: Easy-to-build social applications
  • Creator Monetization: Native token and NFT integration
  • Censorship Resistance: No single point of control

Developer Opportunities

The Base app ecosystem presents significant opportunities for developers:

Mini App Development:

  • Low barrier to entry with comprehensive SDKs
  • Built-in user base through Base app distribution
  • Viral potential through social integration
  • Multiple monetization options

Success Stories:

  • ZORA: Creator coins and content monetization
  • BankerCoin: Trading and transaction automation
  • Noice: Micro-tipping and creator coin distribution
  • QR Coin: Dynamic billboard advertising through QR auctions
  • DeFi Interfaces: Direct protocol access within the app

Market Impact: The Exchange Wars

The Race for Exchange Blockchains

Multiple major exchanges are pursuing similar strategies:

Coinbase (Base):

  • First-mover advantage in US market
  • Strong regulatory compliance
  • Institutional trust and backing

OKX (X Layer):

  • Recent 100%+ pump in OKB token
  • Focus on Asian markets
  • Advanced trading features

Binance (BNB Chain):

  • Established ecosystem with largest user base
  • Strong international presence
  • Comprehensive DeFi integration

Kraken (Inc L2):

  • Traditional finance integration
  • Professional trader focus
  • Regulatory compliance emphasis

Token Economics and Valuations

The exchange blokchain trend is driving significant value creation:

BNB Example:

  • Market cap: ~$100 billion
  • Exceeds Coinbase's equity valuation (~$84 billion)
  • Demonstrates token premium over traditional equity

Implications for Coinbase:

  • Potential Base token could double company's valuation
  • Regulatory clarity improving launch prospects
  • Investor pressure mounting for tokenization

Why the Base App Could Win

Unique Advantages

1. Regulatory Clarity

  • US-based with clear compliance framework
  • Trump administration crypto-friendly policies
  • Established relationships with regulators

2. User Experience Focus

  • Mobile-first design philosophy
  • Intuitive interface for crypto newcomers
  • Seamless onboarding from traditional finance

3. Ecosystem Integration

  • Direct fiat on/off ramps
  • Credit card integration
  • Traditional payment methods

4. Developer Support

  • Comprehensive documentation
  • Active developer community
  • Regular hackathons and boot camps
  • Financial incentives for builders

Network Effects

The Base app is designed to create powerful network effects:

  • More users attract more developers
  • More apps provide more utility
  • More utility drives more user adoption
  • More adoption increases token value and ecosystem rewards

Investment Opportunities

Direct Plays

Aerodrome (AERO):

  • Primary liquidity provider for Base
  • Direct integration benefits
  • Lower market cap than competitors
  • Significant upside as Base app scales

Farcaster Ecosystem:

  • Potential token launch expected
  • $180M raised in funding
  • Critical infrastructure provider
  • Mini app revenue sharing potential

Indirect Beneficiaries

Zora (ZORA):

  • Social layer integration
  • Creator economy infrastructure
  • NFT and creator coin platforms
  • Growing adoption metrics

Base Ecosystem Tokens:

  • Early-stage projects building on Base
  • Mini app tokens and creator coins
  • Protocol tokens with Base integration

Risks and Challenges

Technical Risks

Scalability Concerns:

  • L2 transaction capacity limitations
  • User experience during high demand
  • Cross-chain interoperability challenges

Competition Intensity:

  • Multiple well-funded competitors
  • Rapid feature copying
  • User acquisition costs

Regulatory Risks

Token Launch Uncertainty:

  • SEC approval for Base token unclear
  • Potential classification issues
  • Compliance costs and restrictions

International Expansion:

  • Varying regulatory frameworks
  • Competition from local players
  • Operational complexity

Market Risks

Narrative Rotation:

  • Crypto market attention spans shortening
  • Base narrative may be temporary
  • Other sectors could emerge as dominant

The Broader Implications

Industry Transformation

The success of super apps could fundamentally change crypto:

User Behavior:

  • Single app for all crypto needs
  • Reduced friction for newcomers
  • Higher engagement and retention

Developer Economics:

  • Platform dependency risks
  • Revenue sharing models
  • Innovation constraints vs. opportunities

Market Structure:

  • Exchange consolidation pressures
  • Middleware protocol opportunities
  • New value capture mechanisms

Traditional Finance Disruption

Crypto super apps pose a direct threat to:

  • Traditional payment processors
  • Social media platforms
  • Financial services companies
  • E-commerce platforms

Getting Started: Early Access Strategy

For Users

Current Status: Limited beta with waitlist Access Methods:

  • Team invitations only (no user referrals)
  • Active development with user feedback integration
  • Expected full launch within 1-2 months

Preparation Steps:

  1. Follow Base and Coinbase social channels
  2. Engage with Base ecosystem projects
  3. Participate in developer communities
  4. Build early adoption portfolio positions

For Developers

Opportunity Windows:

  • Mini app development with Farcaster SDK
  • Base ecosystem tool creation
  • Creator economy infrastructure
  • Cross-chain bridge solutions

Long-Term Vision

The Base app represents more than just another crypto platform – it's a bet on the future of digital interaction. Success could establish Coinbase as the dominant force in crypto user experience, while failure could cede ground to more agile competitors.

Key Success Metrics to Watch

User Adoption:

  • Daily active users growth
  • Transaction volume trends
  • User retention rates
  • Geographic expansion

Developer Ecosystem:

  • Mini app quantity and quality
  • Developer retention rates
  • Revenue sharing distributions
  • Innovation rate

Market Performance:

  • Base ecosystem token performance
  • Trading volume growth
  • Creator economy metrics
  • Cross-platform integrations

Conclusion

The Coinbase Base app represents a potentially transformative moment in crypto infrastructure. By combining social features, trading capabilities, and developer tools into a single platform, it could become the primary gateway for mainstream crypto adoption.

For investors and developers, the opportunity lies not just in the Base app itself, but in the entire ecosystem it's creating. Early positioning in Base-native projects, particularly those with lower market caps and strong integration potential, could yield significant returns as the platform scales.

However, success is far from guaranteed. The competitive landscape is intense, regulatory challenges remain, and crypto market narratives shift rapidly. The winners will be those who can execute flawlessly while adapting to changing market conditions.

The race for the crypto super app is just beginning – and the Base app has taken an early lead.

Stay ahead of crypto infrastructure trends. The platforms that win user mindshare today will shape the industry's future tomorrow.

Build Smarter Crypto Apps &
AI Agents in Minutes, Not Months
Real-time prices, trading signals, and on-chain insights all from one powerful API.
Grab a Free API Key
Token Metrics Team
Token Metrics Team

Recent Posts

Research

REST API Explained: Design, Use Cases & Best Practices

Token Metrics Team
5
MIN

REST APIs are the backbone of modern web and mobile integrations. This guide breaks down core concepts, practical design patterns, and operational practices so engineers and product teams can evaluate, build, and maintain resilient RESTful services.

What is a REST API and why it matters

Representational State Transfer (REST) is an architectural style for distributed systems. A REST API exposes resources—typically represented as JSON or XML—over HTTP using standard verbs such as GET, POST, PUT, PATCH, and DELETE. The simplicity and ubiquity of REST make it a go-to choice for connecting microservices, mobile apps, and third-party integrations.

When assessing a REST API, focus on clarity of resource modeling, consistency of endpoints, and predictable use of HTTP semantics. Well-designed REST APIs reduce onboarding friction, simplify client code, and enable easier testing and monitoring across a heterogeneous environment.

Core principles and design patterns

Apply a few core principles to make a REST API robust and maintainable:

  • Resource-first design: Model nouns (users, orders, transactions) as resources with clear URIs, e.g., /api/v1/users/{id}.
  • Statelessness: Each request should contain all information needed to process it. This simplifies load balancing and scaling.
  • HTTP semantics: Use status codes (200, 201, 204, 400, 401, 404, 429, 500) appropriately and document their meaning for each endpoint.
  • Versioning: Prefer explicit versioning (/v1/) or content negotiation to avoid breaking clients when you evolve APIs.
  • Pagination and filtering: For list endpoints, implement cursor-based pagination and consistent filtering/query parameters to keep payloads bounded.

Pattern-based approaches—such as HATEOAS (hypermedia links), idempotent write operations, and resource representations optimized for client needs—help balance flexibility with performance. Choose patterns that align with your ecosystem and developer experience goals.

Authentication, rate limiting, and error handling

Security and reliability are non-negotiable. Common authentication options include API keys, OAuth 2.0 bearer tokens, and mutual TLS for service-to-service communication. For public APIs, use scopes and granular permissions.

Rate limiting and throttling protect backend systems from spikes and can be implemented at API gateway or service mesh layers. Communicate limits via headers (e.g., X-RateLimit-Remaining) and return 429 responses with retry guidance.

Error handling should be consistent and machine-readable. A common pattern is a top-level error object with code, message, and optionally a trace or documentation URL. For example:

  1. Return 4xx for client errors with actionable messages.
  2. Return 5xx for server-side failures and include correlation IDs for debugging.
  3. Document idempotency behavior for POST/PUT when retries are possible.

Practical use cases and integration patterns

REST APIs are used across many scenarios. Typical patterns include:

  • Backend-for-frontend (BFF): A thin API tailored to a specific client type (web, mobile) to aggregate multiple services.
  • Service composition: Use REST endpoints to compose business flows across microservices with clear contracts and fallbacks.
  • Event-driven hybrid: Combine REST for synchronous queries and webhooks or message queues for asynchronous events.

When integrating third-party REST APIs, perform a compatibility audit: authentication model, rate limits, data formats, error semantics, and SLA expectations. Automated contract tests (e.g., Pact) and API specifications (OpenAPI/Swagger) reduce integration risk and speed up CI/CD pipelines.

Testing, monitoring, and observability

Operational maturity for REST APIs comes from layered testing and observability:

  • Contract and regression tests: Use OpenAPI to generate tests and validate responses against schemas.
  • Load and chaos testing: Validate behavior under realistic and degraded conditions, including simulated rate-limit breaches and latency spikes.
  • Tracing and metrics: Instrument endpoints with request latency, error rates, and throughput. Distributed tracing helps correlate calls across services.

Expose health checks (liveness, readiness) and use alerting thresholds anchored to business metrics (e.g., error budget, p95 latency). Observability data enables root-cause analysis and informs capacity planning.

Build Smarter Crypto Apps & AI Agents with Token Metrics

Token Metrics provides real-time prices, trading signals, and on-chain insights all from one powerful API. Grab a Free API Key

FAQ: What is REST and how does it differ from other styles?

REST is an architectural style emphasizing resources exposed over HTTP with stateless interactions and use of standard verbs. It differs from RPC (remote procedure call) in its resource orientation and from GraphQL in its single-endpoint query flexibility versus REST's multiple resource-oriented endpoints.

How should I version a REST API?

Common strategies include URI versioning (/v1/) and header-based versioning. URI versioning is explicit and simpler for clients; header-based supports smoother evolution. Choose a strategy early and document migration steps.

What are best practices for securing REST APIs?

Use TLS, enforce authentication/authorization, rotate credentials, implement least privilege, validate inputs to prevent injection, and rate-limit to mitigate abuse. For machine-to-machine traffic, consider mTLS or OAuth 2.0 client credentials flow.

How do I monitor and troubleshoot APIs in production?

Collect metrics (latency, error rates), logs, and traces. Correlate these with business KPIs and use correlation IDs to trace individual requests. Automated synthetic monitoring can detect endpoint regressions before users are impacted.

When should I choose REST vs GraphQL or gRPC?

Choose REST for simplicity, widespread tooling, and resource-centric models. GraphQL fits use cases where clients need flexible queries and reduced round-trips. gRPC excels at low-latency service-to-service calls with strict typing. Evaluate client needs, network constraints, and ecosystem tooling.

Can AI-driven tooling improve API development and research?

AI tools can accelerate schema design, generate client SDKs, detect anomalous traffic patterns, and prioritize technical debt. Platforms that combine market and on-chain data with API access can help teams prototype integrations and analyze usage patterns—explore platforms like Token Metrics for AI-driven insights relevant to crypto data APIs.

Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only. It explains technical concepts related to REST APIs and operational best practices. It does not provide investment advice, recommendations, or endorsements. Evaluate tools and architectural choices independently based on your requirements and constraints.

Research

How REST APIs Power Modern Apps

Token Metrics Team
5
MIN

APIs are the connective tissue of modern software. Among architectural styles, the REST API remains a dominant approach for exposing resources over HTTP. This article explains what REST APIs are, the principles behind them, practical design patterns, security and testing considerations, and how AI-driven tools can streamline API development and analysis without prescribing decisions.

What a REST API Is and When to Use It

REST (Representational State Transfer) is an architectural style for distributed systems that emphasizes stateless interactions, resource-oriented URLs, and standard HTTP verbs (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE, etc.). A REST API exposes resources as endpoints that clients can interact with using these verbs and common data formats such as JSON.

REST APIs are well-suited for web and mobile backends, microservices communication, and public developer platforms because they leverage ubiquitous HTTP tooling and are language-agnostic. They are not a one-size-fits-all: scenarios with complex subscriptions, real-time streaming, or highly stateful workflows may benefit from complementary technologies (e.g., WebSockets, gRPC, GraphQL).

Core Principles and Architecture Patterns

Understanding core REST principles helps teams design predictable, maintainable interfaces. Key concepts include:

  • Resources and URIs: Model domain entities (users, orders, posts) as resources with clear, hierarchical URIs (e.g., /users/{id}/orders).
  • HTTP Methods & Semantics: Use methods to express intent—GET for retrieval, POST for creation, PUT/PATCH for updates, DELETE for removal.
  • Statelessness: Each request should contain all necessary context. Stateless servers scale better and simplify load balancing.
  • Representation: Return consistent representations (JSON, sometimes XML) and use standard status codes (200, 201, 400, 404, 500) for clarity.
  • HATEOAS (optional): Hypermedia links in responses can guide clients through available actions, though many APIs omit full HATEOAS due to complexity.

Architectural patterns to consider:

  1. Layered Services: Keep routing, business logic, and persistence separable for testability and reusability.
  2. API Gateway: Consolidate cross-cutting concerns like authentication, rate limiting, and logging at a gateway in front of microservices.
  3. Versioning: Use URI versioning (/v1/) or header-based approaches to evolve APIs without breaking existing clients.

Common Design Patterns and Best Practices

Practical design choices reduce friction for integrators and improve operational reliability. Consider these tactics:

  • Consistent Naming: Prefer nouns for resources and keep pluralization consistent (e.g., /users, /products).
  • Pagination & Filtering: Implement pagination for large collections (cursor or offset patterns) and provide robust query filtering with clear parameter semantics.
  • Idempotency: Make write operations idempotent where possible (PUT) or support idempotency keys for POST operations to safeguard against retries.
  • Error Handling: Return structured error objects with codes, messages, and request IDs to aid debugging.
  • Rate Limits & Quotas: Expose headers that indicate remaining quota and reset intervals so clients can adapt to limits gracefully.
  • API Contracts & Documentation: Maintain machine-readable contracts (OpenAPI/Swagger) and human-friendly docs that include examples and schema definitions.

Security-related best practices include enforcing TLS, validating inputs, and applying the principle of least privilege for resource access. Authentication options commonly used are API keys, OAuth 2.0, and JWTs; select an approach aligned with threat models and compliance needs.

Testing, Monitoring, and AI-Enhanced Tooling

Robust testing and observability are essential for reliable REST APIs. Typical testing layers include unit tests for business logic, integration tests for endpoints, and contract tests against OpenAPI specifications. Synthetic monitoring and instrumentation (tracing, metrics, structured logs) surface latency trends, error spikes, and usage patterns.

AI-driven tools and analytics can accelerate development and maintenance without replacing human judgment. Use cases include:

  • Automated Contract Generation: Tools can infer or validate OpenAPI schemas from traffic traces to identify undocumented endpoints.
  • Anomaly Detection: ML models can flag abnormal error rates or latency regressions earlier than manual review cycles.
  • Code Assistance: AI can suggest endpoint implementations, input validation logic, and test cases to speed iteration.

When integrating AI tools, validate outputs and maintain clear governance: model suggestions should be reviewed, and generated specs must be tested against realistic scenarios.

Build Smarter Crypto Apps & AI Agents with Token Metrics

Token Metrics provides real-time prices, trading signals, and on-chain insights all from one powerful API. Grab a Free API Key

What is the difference between REST and RESTful?

REST describes the architectural principles; "RESTful" is an adjective applied to services that follow those principles. In practice, developers use the terms interchangeably to describe HTTP-based APIs that model resources and use standard verbs.

How should I version a REST API?

Versioning strategies include URI versioning (e.g., /v1/resource), header-based versioning, or content negotiation. Choose a consistent approach and document migration paths. Semantic versioning for the API spec and clear deprecation schedules help clients adapt.

Which authentication method is recommended?

Selection depends on use case: API keys are simple for server-to-server calls; OAuth 2.0 provides delegated access for user-centric flows; JWTs enable stateless session tokens. Evaluate threat models, token lifecycle, and revocation needs before choosing.

How can I make my API more resilient?

Introduce retries with exponential backoff, circuit breakers, idempotency keys for write operations, and graceful degradation on dependent service failures. Also, ensure comprehensive monitoring and alerting so operators can react to incidents swiftly.

What tools should I use for documenting and testing?

OpenAPI/Swagger is the de facto standard for API contracts and interactive docs. Postman and Insomnia are popular for exploratory testing; CI-driven contract tests and integration test suites validate expected behavior. Use static analysis and linting (e.g., Spectral) to enforce consistency.

How do rate limits affect API design?

Rate limits protect backend resources and ensure fair usage. Design endpoints so that expensive operations are clearly documented, offer bulk or async endpoints for heavy workloads, and provide clear limit headers so clients can adapt request rates.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational and technical guidance only. It does not provide financial, legal, or investment advice. Implementations should be validated against project requirements, security standards, and applicable regulations.

Research

Practical REST API Guide for Developers

Token Metrics Team
5
MIN

REST APIs power much of the web and modern applications by providing a simple, scalable contract between clients and servers. Whether you're building microservices, mobile backends, or integrations, understanding REST principles, security trade-offs, and operational practices helps you design reliable interfaces that scale. This guide walks through core concepts, design patterns, security essentials, and practical steps to evaluate and implement REST APIs effectively.

What is a REST API and why it matters

REST (Representational State Transfer) is an architectural style for distributed systems. Rather than a strict protocol, REST prescribes patterns: stateless interactions, resource-oriented URIs, and use of standard HTTP methods (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE, PATCH). The result is a predictable API surface that is easy to cache, route, and evolve.

Key benefits include:

  • Interoperability: Clients and servers can evolve independently when contracts are clear.
  • Scalability: Statelessness facilitates horizontal scaling and load balancing.
  • Tooling: Wide ecosystem for testing, documentation, and client generation.

Design principles and best practices

Good REST design balances simplicity, clarity, and forward compatibility. Use the following framework when designing endpoints and contracts:

  1. Resource modeling: Identify nouns (resources) first, then actions. Prefer /users/123/orders over /getUserOrders?id=123.
  2. HTTP methods & status codes: Map CRUD operations to HTTP verbs and return meaningful status codes (200, 201, 204, 400, 404, 422, 500).
  3. Pagination & filtering: Standardize pagination (limit/offset or cursor) and provide filtering query parameters to avoid large payloads.
  4. Versioning strategy: Favor versioning in the path (e.g., /v1/) or via headers. Keep deprecation timelines and migration guides clear to consumers.
  5. HATEOAS (optional): Hypermedia can add discoverability, but many practical APIs use simple documented links instead.

Document expected request/response schemas and examples. Tools like OpenAPI (Swagger) make it easier to generate client libraries and validate contracts.

Security, authentication, and common patterns

Security is a non-functional requirement that must be addressed from day one. Common authentication and authorization patterns include:

  • OAuth 2.0: Widely used for delegated access and third-party integrations.
  • API keys: Simple for service-to-service or internal integrations, but should be scoped and rotated.
  • JWT (JSON Web Tokens): Stateless tokens carrying claims; be mindful of token expiration and revocation strategies.

Practical security measures:

  • Always use TLS (HTTPS) to protect data in transit.
  • Validate and sanitize inputs to prevent injection attacks and resource exhaustion.
  • Rate limit and apply quota controls to reduce abuse and manage capacity.
  • Monitor authentication failures and anomalous patterns; implement alerting and incident playbooks.

Testing, performance, and observability

APIs must be reliable in production. Build a test matrix that covers unit tests, contract tests, and end-to-end scenarios. Useful practices include:

  • Contract testing: Use OpenAPI-based validation to ensure client and server expectations remain aligned.
  • Load testing: Simulate realistic traffic to identify bottlenecks and capacity limits.
  • Caching: Use HTTP cache headers (ETag, Cache-Control) and edge caching for read-heavy endpoints.
  • Observability: Instrument APIs with structured logs, distributed traces, and metrics (latency, error rates, throughput).

Operationally, design for graceful degradation: return useful error payloads, implement retries with exponential backoff on clients, and provide clear SLAs. AI-driven research and API analytics can help prioritize which endpoints to optimize; for example, Token Metrics illustrates how product data combined with analytics surfaces high-impact areas for improvement.

Build Smarter Crypto Apps & AI Agents with Token Metrics

Token Metrics provides real-time prices, trading signals, and on-chain insights all from one powerful API. Grab a Free API Key

Frequently Asked Questions

What exactly does "REST" mean?

REST stands for Representational State Transfer. It describes a set of constraints—stateless interactions, resource-oriented URIs, and uniform interfaces—rather than a wire protocol. Implementations typically use HTTP and JSON.

How is REST different from SOAP and GraphQL?

SOAP is a strict protocol with XML envelopes, formal contracts (WSDL), and built-in features like WS-Security. REST is more flexible and lightweight. GraphQL exposes a single endpoint that allows clients to request specific fields, reducing over-fetching but adding complexity on the server side. Choose based on client needs, tooling, and team expertise.

What are common authentication methods for REST APIs?

Common methods include OAuth 2.0 for delegated access, API keys for simple service access, and JWTs for stateless sessions. Each has trade-offs around revocation, token size, and complexity—consider lifecycle and threat models when selecting an approach.

How should I manage API versioning?

Versioning strategies include path-based (/v1/resource), header-based, or content negotiation. Path-based versioning is the most explicit and easiest for clients. Maintain backward compatibility where possible and provide clear deprecation timelines and migration guides.

Which tools help with designing and testing REST APIs?

OpenAPI (Swagger) for specification and client generation, Postman for exploratory testing, and contract-testing tools like Pact for ensuring compatibility. Load testing tools (k6, JMeter) and observability platforms complete the pipeline for production readiness.

Disclaimer

This article is educational and technical in nature. It provides general information about REST API design, security, and operations, not financial, legal, or investment advice. Assess your own requirements and consult appropriate specialists when implementing systems in production.

Choose from Platinum, Gold, and Silver packages
Reach with 25–30% open rates and 0.5–1% CTR
Craft your own custom ad—from banners to tailored copy
Perfect for Crypto Exchanges, SaaS Tools, DeFi, and AI Products